Should I overpay my student loan? Plan 2 and Plan 5 worked examples (2026)
For most graduates on Plan 2 or Plan 5, overpaying a student loan means paying more in total, because the balance is written off. Worked examples show who it saves money for, who it costs, and better places for the money.
In this guideShowHide
Why a student loan is not like other debt
With a credit card or a mortgage, paying it off sooner always saves interest. A UK student loan works differently:
- You repay a share of your income, not of your balance. It is 9% of what you earn above your plan's threshold (6% for a postgraduate loan). On Plan 2 the threshold is £29,385 for 2026/27, and it is frozen there until April 2030.
- It is written off. Plan 2 and postgraduate loans are written off 30 years after the April you were first due to repay, Plan 5 after 40 years, and newer Plan 1 loans after 25.
- Interest only matters if you will actually repay it. If the balance will be written off, the interest added to it never costs you anything.
So the real question is not "how big is my balance?" but "will I ever clear it?". If you will not, your monthly repayments are effectively a 9% graduate tax, and overpaying just adds to it.
Worked examples
These use the calculator with a 3% pay rise each year and 3% inflation from 2027. All figures are in future pounds and are estimates.
Plan 2, £45,000 balance, first due to repay in April 2020, overpaying £100 a month:
| Salary today | Without overpaying | With £100 a month extra | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| £35,000 | Repay about £24,300, rest written off in 2050 | Repay about £52,300, still written off | Overpaying costs about £28,000 more |
| £50,000 | Repay about £69,900, rest written off in 2050 | Clear it in 2046, repaying about £80,700 | Overpaying costs about £10,800 more |
| £70,000 | Clear it in 2041, repaying about £69,400 | Clear it in 2037, repaying about £62,200 | Overpaying saves about £7,300 |
Plan 5, £50,000 balance, salary £28,000, first due in April 2027: you would repay about £19,200 over 40 years without overpaying. Adding £100 a month takes that to about £67,600, and the loan is still written off. Overpaying costs about £48,400 more.
The pattern is clear: overpaying only pays off for people who were going to clear the loan anyway.
When overpaying can make sense
- You are a high earner and the calculator shows you clearing the loan well before write-off, even without overpaying.
- Your balance is small compared to your salary, for example an older Plan 1 loan with a few thousand pounds left.
- You want it gone for peace of mind and are happy to pay a bit more for that. That is a valid choice, as long as you make it knowing the cost.
Even then, overpaying is rarely urgent. Interest on Plans 1, 4 and 5 is 4.1% for 2026/27, and Plan 2 is capped at 6%. Paying off a credit card at 20% or more, or getting an employer's matched pension contribution, almost always comes first.
Free one-page sheet
Every UK money number for 2026/27 on one page
Tax bands, National Insurance, ISA limits, savings and side income allowances, student loan thresholds and the key dates. Free when you join The Weekly Upgrade, one useful email every Thursday.
Better places for the money
If the calculator says your loan will be written off, these usually do more for you:
- An emergency fund. Three to six months of essentials in an easy access account. See our emergency fund guide.
- Expensive debt. Clear credit cards, overdrafts and car finance first. The debt payoff calculator shows the fastest order.
- A Lifetime ISA, if you are 18 to 39 and saving for a first home. The government adds 25%, up to £1,000 a year. See Lifetime ISA explained.
- Your pension. Paying more in, especially through salary sacrifice, gets tax relief, and it can even reduce your student loan repayments because they are worked out on your pay after salary sacrifice. See workplace pensions explained.
- A stocks and shares ISA for long-term goals. Compare the cheapest stocks and shares ISAs. Investing puts your capital at risk.
What about getting a mortgage?
Your student loan does not show on your credit file. Mortgage lenders do count the monthly repayment as an outgoing when they work out how much you can borrow, but the effect is usually small. Overpaying does not reduce your monthly repayment, because that is set by your salary, so it does not help your mortgage application either. Putting the money towards your deposit usually helps far more.
How to overpay, if you decide to
You can make extra payments at any time through your online student loan account, as a one-off or by Direct Debit. There is no penalty for overpaying, but there is also no way to get the money back once it is paid, unless you have paid more than you owe.
Free toolStudent loan repayment calculatorWhat you repay each month on Plan 1, 2, 4, 5 or a postgraduate loan, when it is written off, and whether overpaying helps.Common questions
Is it worth paying off my student loan early?
For most people on Plan 2 or Plan 5, no, because the loan will be written off before it is repaid and overpaying increases what you pay in total. It can be worth it if you earn enough to clear the loan anyway. Run your numbers in the calculator to see which group you are in.
Does my student loan balance matter?
Less than most people think. Your monthly repayment depends only on your salary. The balance only matters if you are likely to repay it in full before it is written off.
Will my student loan be written off?
Many will. On Plan 2, a large share of graduates are not expected to repay in full within 30 years, and Plan 5's 40-year term with a lower threshold means more people repay more. Whether yours is written off depends on your balance, your salary and how it grows.
Should I pay off my student loan before saving for a house?
Usually not. A deposit, ideally boosted by a Lifetime ISA bonus, does far more for your mortgage options. Overpaying your student loan does not lower your monthly repayment, which is what lenders look at.
Can I get a refund if I overpaid?
If you have paid more than you owed, or had repayments taken while earning under the threshold for the whole tax year, you can usually claim the money back from the Student Loans Company.
This is general information, not personal tax or financial advice. Tax rules change and depend on your circumstances, so check GOV.UK or speak to an accountant before acting.
Keep reading
What to read next
Free one-page sheet
Every UK money number for 2026/27 on one page
Tax bands, National Insurance, ISA limits, savings and side income allowances, student loan thresholds and the key dates. Free when you join The Weekly Upgrade, one useful email every Thursday.